If you need a truck with some serious performance specs, both the GMC Sierra 2500 and the Chevy Silverado have been top choices for years. But while they’re both great trucks, they do serve different markets and just because one is a great choice for you doesn’t mean the other one will be.
So, which truck is right for you? It depends on what you’re looking for. And to help you make up your mind and find the perfect truck for you we’ve highlighted some of the top features for each truck and how they differ from each other for you here.
If you’re in the market for a powerful truck with a touch of style and comfort, it’s hard to top the GMC Sierra 2500. The first GMC Sierra 2500 hit the road in 1988, and since then there have been five different generation Sierra 2500s. We’ve highlighted some of the most important performance specs for you to consider here.
The GMC Sierra 2500 has tons of engine options through the years, but every one of them was a V8 engine, although there are plenty of both gasoline and diesel powertrains to pick from. Older generation Sierra 1500s used a 5.3L, 6.0L, 7.4L, 5.7L, and even a 6.5L diesel engine, while newer generations simplified things a bit.
Starting with the 4th generation Sierra 2500, which hit the market in 2014, is a 6.0L Vortec engine and a 6.6L Duramax Diesel, the same engines you’ll find in the corresponding Silverado 2500s. Meanwhile, the fifth-generation Sierra 2500s, which came out in 2020, still use the 6.6L Duramax Diesel, but they ditch the 6.0L Vortec engine.
Instead, they use a 6.6L turbocharged gasoline engine that pushes 401 horsepower and 464 lb-ft of torque. Those are both impressive numbers, but they still can’t keep up with the 6.6L Duramax engine that pushes 445 horsepower and 910 lb-ft of torque during the same model years.
The towing numbers of a GMC Sierra 2500 vary quite a bit depending on the generation and package you go with. The first-generation Sierra 2500s could “only” tow between 4,000 and 8,500 pounds, but if you’re looking at a fifth-generation 2500 those numbers explode out to a maximum of 14,500 pounds.
Third-generation Sierra 2500s hit the market in 2007 and could tow up to 13,000 pounds, while fourth-generation Sierras can tow up to 14,000 pounds.
But no matter what generation Sierra 2500 you go with you need to look at the specific towing capacity for that truck. There are tons of different packages and variations, and these significantly affect how much each one can tow!
While the Silverado 2500 isn’t quite as old as the GMC Sierra 2500, the Silverado 2500 does go back to 2001. This means there’s plenty of history and trucks to pick from, and in many ways the Silverado 2500 is extremely similar to the Sierra 2500.
We’ll highlight exactly how they’re similar and where they differ so you can make an informed decision about which one is right for you here.
Part of getting a more powerful truck is figuring out what’s underneath the hood. With the Silverado 2500, the answer pretty much always comes down to one of two engine options, either the 6.0L Vortec V8 gasoline engine or the 6.6L Duramax Diesel.
The exact performance specs of each engine will vary a bit depending on the model year you go with, but overall they stay pretty similar. The Vortec engine pushes between 353 and 360 horsepower and provides between 373 and 380 lb-ft of torque, with newer model years producing performance numbers near the higher end of those ranges.
Meanwhile, the Duramax diesel engine’s low-end horsepower numbers start at 360, but they top out at 397 horsepower on the newer 2500s. Meanwhile, where you really see the performance numbers improve is with the torque.
Even the least powerful Duramax engines in a 2500 push 650 lb-ft of torque, and on newer models that number jumps all the way to 765 lb-ft of torque!
The towing capacity of the Silverado 2500 has changed quite a bit through the years, but no matter how you want to look at it the Silverado 2500 is a powerful work truck through and through. The first-generation Silverado 2500 can tow anywhere between 9,700 and 12,000 pounds, while a second-generation Silverado (which hit the market in 2007) can tow between 9,300 and 16,700 pounds.
The newest Silverado 2500s can tow anywhere between 13,000 and 18,600 pounds, actually outperforming the most powerful Sierra 2500s in this category.
The Silverado 2500 is a working man’s truck through and through, and because of that performance is paramount, and the Silverado 2500 delivers.
Whether you decide to go with a Sierra 2500 or a Silverado 2500 you’re getting a powerful ¾-ton pickup truck that can handle a ton of different jobs. But while they’re both great trucks, there’s certainly an advantage to one or the other depending on what you want.
Generally, the advantage of a Silverado 2500 comes in terms of the performance specs and the price. The top-performing Silverado 2500s can tow more than the top-performing Sierra 2500s, but neither truck slacks in the performance department.
Meanwhile, the Sierra 2500 generally has more comfort and technological features than the Silverado 2500. Of course, this is going to depend on the trim levels and packages you go with, but high-end Sierra 2500s will have more features than high-end Silverado 2500s from the same model year.
Do you want either a Silverado 2500 or a Sierra 2500? The experts at Tim’s Truck would love to help you track down exactly what you’re looking for. Not only that, but they’ll happily answer any questions you might have and help you figure out which option is right for you if you’re still a little unsure!